Biostimulator injections & facial aging
Biostimulation is the term used to describe a method to stimulate your immune system to produce collagen. Injectables are employed to awaken your collagen producing cells known as fibroblasts, in turn preventing further collagen loss. Think of biostimulators as agents to mitigate facial aging. Biostimulator injections are different from dermal fillers which correct volume loss.
SummaryBiostimulation Summarised
- This term refers to the stimulation of cells that produce collagen
- Injectable provide low levels of biostimulation, in turn reducing future age-related collagen degradation
- The type of collagen stimulating injectable depend on factors such as the degree of dermal hydration, background sun damage, volume loss & age
- Biostimulation is important around perimenopausal as collagen loss accelerates around this time (about 30% reduction in 5 years)
What are biostimulator injections?
This group of injectables herald a new frontier in anti-aging medicine. They help stimulate cells known as fibroblasts to continue producing collagen & elastin, in turn slowing down the aging process. Think of biostimulatory injectables as preventive treatments.
Here is an analogy. Patients visit dentists for two main reasons-
- Treatment of a symptom- the most common is a toothache. This is akin to visiting a dermatologist for correction of volume loss, or wrinkles. A dentist will drill or extract, I will inject to correct age related volume deficit, or prescribe a series of laser treatments to remove wrinkles & or improve laxity.
- Prevention. Dentists will clean & scale, add fluoride & encourage flossing, & brushing. This can prevent decay & hence reduce the chances of symptomatic treatment. In my work, this is akin to biostimulatory injectables. The aim to prolong the need for me to correct a symptom (volume loss, collagen loss, aging).
Why invest in biostimulators?
Think of these injectables as prevention. They form the second form of defence after skin care such as antioxidants & sunscreen.
Dermal fillers, anti-wrinkle injections, lasers & energy devices, used appropriately can reverse aging, whilst biostimulators slow down the aging process. Prevent before treating.
What results can you expect?
Ignore, for now, the marketing of these injectables by parent companies. The true aim of biostimulators is to keep your collagen producing cells viable & active as you age.
Primary aims: Mitigation of collagen loss with resulting wrinkles, skin laxity & loss of elasticity. Hence in the true definition, these injectables are used to slow down the aging process. For mature patients, tissue hydration is important. This will be discussed in detail shortly.
Secondary gain: Collagen stimulation of various degrees to provide objective skin tightening & firmness. In some patients we see a reverse of aging, namely less wrinkles & lifting of key areas such as the lower face & neck area. Skin tightening depends largely on your immune system & how much collagen you can produce.
Tertiary results: improvement of skin quality, meaning better skin texture, less fine lines & a reduction in pore sizing.
View our Treatment Gallery
What is the evidence supporting biostimulatory injectables?
Bioremodelling agents such as collagen stimulators have a robust body of evidence that covers over a decade of research. Australia has been slow on the uptake of these injectables. The first dedicated biostimulatory injectable was only introduced in 2022.
Download these papers to understand more about biostimulatory injectables:
Collagen stimulating injectables
How do they differ from dermal fillers?
Dermal fillers provide volume, biostimulators are designed to stimulate collagen with minimal changes to volume. In most cases volume refers to correction of fat & bone atrophy, which occurs with age. Biostimulators are aimed at the upper layers of skin.
Type of injectable | Dermal Filler | Biostimulatory injections |
Volume replacement | Marked. | Minimal. |
Level of action | Bone & fat > dermal | Dermal layer |
Collagen stimulation | Minimal | Moderate to marked |
Exceptions apply, as there are dermal fillers that can have both volume replacement as well as biostimulatory actions, depending on the properties & dilution of the liquid. It’s complex.
What types of biostimulators are there?
Two main types of biostimulators, hyaluronic acid based & non-HA based.
- HA based: High and low molecular weight, non-cross linked. Profhilo
- Non-HA based: PLLA, PDLLA, PCL, Polynucleotide, CAH
Hyaluronic acid based biostimulators provide better tissue hydration with some aspects of collagen stimulation. Non-HA based compounds provide better collagen stimulation with minor to modest volume changes (based upon dilution). They do not hydrate skin as well as hyaluronic acid based injectables.
*Hence for patients in their 40s, the best combination includes both HA & non-HA based injectables.
What is the biostimulator of choice for my skin?
The algorithm is complex as I work with different biostimulators & select the most suitable one for your skin type. I take into consideration your age, facial volume, skin quality, degree of background sun damage, dermal hydration levels, target areas as well as your expectations. A rule-
- Late 20s: Non-HA based biostimulators
- 30s-40s: HA based & non-HA based
- 40s-50s: HA based & non-HA volume replacing injectables
- 50s & beyond: HA based & non-HA volume replacing injectables
For a greater understanding of selection, read more.
What is the procedure like?
There are two methods to deliver injectables, needle & cannula. Both methods take between 1-2 minutes to perform. The choice depends on the type & location of the injectable used.
What is recovery like?
Recovery depends on the injectable used & ranges from zero days recovery to 48 hours.
- PLLA or calcium hydroxyapatite biostimulator: no recovery
- Hyaluronic acid biostimulator: 6-hour recovery
- PCL biostimulator: 1–2-day recovery
- Polynucleotide: 48-hour recovery
When will I see the results?
Results can be seen within one to two weeks in patients with dehydrated skin as hyaluronic acid biostimulators (Prohilo) instantly rehydrate the dermis.
Skin firming & tightening however, may take up to 6 months as new collagen requires time to regenerate. This applies to biostimulators such as Sculptra, Radiesse, Gouri & Rejuran.
*The primary aim of bio remodelling agents is to prevent age related collagen depletion. By definition, mitigation is a result you don’t see.
How many treatments will I require?
2-4 depending on your level of collagen loss & dermal hydration. As a guide-
30s to mid 40s: 2 sessions
40s to mid 50s: 3 sessions
50s to 60s & beyond: 3-4 sessions
The exact number of sessions depends on two main factors- the degree of collagen loss & your ability to generate new collagen.
How often will I require biostimulatory injectables?
It depends on your age, expectations & degree of skin aging. As a guide, after the first year-
- HA biostimulators: 1-2 times annually
- Non-HA biostimulators: 1-2 times per year
The older you get, the more frequent the injectables as you will be playing ‘catch-up’, namely replacing collagen depletion with age in addition to mitigating collagen loss with time.
Will biostimulatory injectables really ‘lift’ or ‘tighten’ my skin?
Ignore marketing from clinics & companies. Here is the truth- the primary aim is to reduce age related degradation of collagen. With careful selection of injectable products, this is achievable in most patients (>95%).
As for clinically observable skin tightening, this is seen in 30-70% of patients. The results are dependent upon –
- Correct selection of product
- Dilution of product
- Number of sessions
- Background sun damage
- Age, race & skin condition
- Your genetic response to injectables (that’s the biggest variable)
Summarised: mitigation is something you don’t see, with accurate clinical acumen & selection, most, but not all patients will have clinically evident skin tightening.
When should I start biostimulatory treatments?
A good starting age is in the early stages of collagen loss, namely in the early 30s. Remember, collagen depletion occurs at 1-1.5% per year, starting in the early 20s.
The earlier you start, the less the number of injectable sessions.
Why are biostimulatory injections more important during the menopausal years?
During the first few years of menopause, there is an accelerated decline in collagen- 30% over a span of only 5 years. This, coupled with bone loss & changes in the deep & superficial fat pads leads to accelerated aging in the early 40s to 50s.
Analogy number two. If you move into a house with termites, do you start with renovations or do you prevent further damage from the termites?
Rhetorical question. The same applies to facial aging. The first step is to prevent further degradation of collagen, elastin & hyaluronic acid with biostimulatory injectables (ideally augmented with low-level biostimulants). Invest in prevention, then move to correction.
*Think of aging as the ‘termites of collagen degradation’, by imitating timely treatments one can slow down the decay of time.
How much are treatments?
- HA based high-low biostim: $950 by Davin Lim, $850 by nurses
- CAH biostim: $1290 by Davin Lim, $990 by nurses
- PLLA biostim: $1290 by Davin Lim, $990 by nurses
- PCL biostim: $1290 by Davin Lim, $990 by nurses
- Polynucleotide: $770 by Davin Lim, $720 by nurses
*I use similar biostimulators in Sydney. For appointments, please contact Tracee at Clinic DVP. Book with Kate or myself.
What are hyaluronic acid biostimulators & how do they differ from HA dermal fillers?
The buzz word is Profhilo– the first ‘marketed’ biostimulator/ bioremodelling agent introduced into the Australian market in 2022. IMO, this injectable is overhyped, but necessary (if you are over the age of 40). Why overhyped? Because it is a very weak stimulator of fibroblast (cells that produce collagen). Why is it necessary? Because there is an age related reduction of hyaluronic acid that predisposes to ‘dermal dehydration’ (something HA serums cannot fix).
Profhilo summarized-
- 2-3 sessions spaced 4 to 8 weeks apart
- Minimal downtime of 6-12 hours
- Best used to hydrate the dermal layers of skin
- Can be used on the face, neck & decolletage areas
- I encourage this injectable in just about everyone over 40 years of age
- Best employed with more potent biostimulators that increase collagen production
Type | Volume replacement | Tissue hydration | Collagen stimulation |
Profhilo | Minimal to nil | Class leading maximal hydrating injectable. | Upper layers of dermis (minimal) |
What are polynucleotide bio-injectables, & how good are they?
Polynucleotides are new for Australia. Rejuran is the trade name & is TGA approved for 2023. This compound is derived from DNA extracted from salmon by products (gonads-sperm). It works superficially & stimulates collagen production in the upper layers of skin. This injectable is less powerful than established collagen stimulators such as PLLA, CAH & PCL. It is best used as a preventative, rather than a potent collagen stimulator.
Rejuran summarized
- 3-4 treatment sessions
- Downtime of 48 hours (blebs)
- Requires numbing gel application prior to injection
- Suitable for all skin types
- Best used around the eyes to treat fine lines & wrinkles
- Provides minimal to no volume
- Employed as mitigation over correction of wrinkles
Type | Volume replacement | Tissue hydration | Collagen stimulation |
Minimal to nil | Minimal to nil | Upper layers of skin. |
What is Gouri or PCL - polycaprolactone biostimulation?
This is probably the best biostimulator to enter the Australian market as of 2023. It has a long safety record in Europe & Asia. Gouri provides maximal stimulation of collagen in the lower dermis & requires 3 sessions for optimal results. It can be used on the face & neck area. The downside is that inflammatory responses are more common with this injectable compared to others. This will be TGA approved by 2024.
Gouri Summarised
- 3 sessions, spaced 4-10 weeks apart
- Downtime variable, 1-3 days
- Injections mixed with numbing agent
- Suitable for all skin types
- Takes 3-6 months for optimal results
- Provides little volume, hence ideal for mature lower face
Type | Volume replacement | Tissue hydration | Collagen stimulation |
Gouri (PCL) | Minimal to nil | Minimal to nil | Dermis |
What is poly-L-lactic acid & when do I employ this as a biostimulator?
PLLA is the oldest biostimulatory injectable in Australia with a safety record of two decades. It is also used as a dermal filler as it provides volume in key areas such as the mid-face & temples.
Sculptra summarized
- 3-6 sessions spaced 6-10 weeks apart
- No downtime
- Sculptra can provide improvements in skin quality, but results are not great
- Provides volume in addition to collagen stimulation
- Takes 3-6 months for optimal results
- Best used in the mature age group or volume depleted younger age group
Type | Volume replacement | Tissue hydration | Collagen stimulation |
Sculptra | Moderate + | Minimal | Lower layers of dermis |
What is calcium hydroxyapatite?
Also known as Radiesse, this powerful remodelling agent is flexible in its delivery. I use this to remodel atrophic acne scars, however as a dermal filler, it is excellent around the jawline area.
Type | Volume replacement | Tissue hydration | Collagen stimulation |
Radiesse | Moderate | Nil | Mid to lower layers of skin |
What is poly-D-L-lactic acid?
PDLLA is an injectable in Australia that has been applied for TGA approval in 2023. It is also used as a dermal filler as it provides volume in key areas such as the mid-face & temples. The volume effects are faster than PLLA – Sculptra as the particles are more porous (larger surface area).
AestheFill summarized
- 2-3 sessions spaced 6-10 weeks apart
- Possibly more powerful than PLLA- Sculptra
- Is more porous cf. PLLA, hence has a faster ‘immediate’ action
- Provides volume in addition to collagen stimulation
- Takes 3-6 months for optimal results
- Best used in the mature age group or volume depleted younger age group
Type | Volume replacement | Tissue hydration | Collagen stimulation |
AestheFill | Moderate + | Minimal to nil | Lower layers of dermis |
What happens if I stop biostimulatory injectables?
You just age as per your genetic timeline. There is no evidence that stopping injectables will accelerate aging.
How do injectables compare to retinol & other skin care ingredients?
Skin care does not build collagen to a degree of skin firming, nor will it markedly mitigate- reverse collagen. Skin care however is important to improve skin quality, namely provide even skin texture, reduced pigmentation as well as minimize pore sizing & fine lines. A simple skin care routine to reduce UV induced damage to your skin goes like this-
- AM: Antioxidants (Vitamin C, E), SPF
- PM: Retinol
Skin care forms the cornerstone of preventing UV induced photodamage, however in the scheme of biostimulation potential, it ranks as (almost) negligible.
For more on skin care, please book an appointment with our dermal therapists or nurses as to product recommendations.
How does LED therapy compare to biostimulator injections?
LEDs are useful treatments to consider, however they are overmarketed & over hyped. LED therapy is most useful for: treatment of acne & recovery following procedures such as lasers or radiofrequency micro needling. LEDs provide very little in the way of collagen stimulation, as compared to biostimulatory injectables.
*We offer these treatments at Cutis Dermatology, Brisbane & Van Park’s Clinic, Sydney. If you would like to consider LED, microneedling & or PRP, book an appointment with our therapists/nurses.
What are the potential side effects of biostimulators?
Fortunately, side effects are rare following biostimulator injections. The injectable of choice with the lowest side effect is hyaluronic acid based biostimulators, or Profhilo.
Non-HA based injectables have a slightly higher rate of side effects including-
- Nodules/lumps & bumps
- Persistent redness
- Post inflammatory pigmentation
- Swelling of approximately 3-5 days
- Allergies
How does microneedling fit into this picture?
Microneedling is a low level biostimulatory procedure that can help improve skin quality & texture. In the scheme of things, it produces marginal effects as compared to lasers & injectables. Provided you are sensible with things, you can perform this procedure at home using a 0.25 mm stamper, roller, or pen.
How does RF microneedling with Morpheus8, Potenza & eMatrix RF fit into this picture?
RFM or radiofrequency microneedling is classed as high level biostimulation, meaning treatments should NOT be performed frequently. Refer to the term conditioned reflex below.
Devices such as Morpheus8, Genius RF & Potenza provide a significant amount of heat over a short period of time. Much like lasers, they can be performed at intervals of 12 to 48 months apart (after a series of sessions).
What are other ways to stimulate collagen if I don’t want injectables?
Your choices are limited to low level biostimulatory devices such as radiofrequency (NuEra or Pelleve), or high level biostimulatory devices such as lasers, chemical peels, HIFU, cog threads (different from mono threads) & other energy devices. Here is a short take on these treatments-
- Lasers & chemical peels are great for skin quality, collagen stimulation is limited to the upper layers of skin. The best laser is CO2, but the downtime is long- up to 2 weeks.
- HIFU: best for fat breakdown of key areas around the jowls & jawline. Can be effective in some patients (no sun damage, thicker dermal layer, more subcutaneous fat).
- Threads: Monofilament PDO threads are a waste of time, cog threads are better, filler threads & anchoring threads are best. They work to ‘lift’ or more accurately reposition sagging skin. Filler thread can stimulate collagen production, however injectables are more predictable, less painful & have a faster recovery.
- RF & RF microneedling: are good treatments for ‘high-heat’, they can help reduce laxity in some patients & provide variable amounts of collagen production. Devices such as Morpheus8, Genius RFM, Infini, Instensif, Secret RFM & Potenza are best combined with injectables.
For more information on the concept of conditioned responses, refer to the section below.
What do I mean with the term conditioned reflex?
Collagen stimulation should be paced. If you keep hitting your fibroblasts with high level biostimulation, chances are you will run out of options within a short period of time. This is termed conditioned reflex. Apply high level stimulation at intervals when required, maintained with low-level biostimulation.
High level biostimulation refers to ablative lasers (like CO2), high intensity RF microneedling (Morpheus8, Profound RF, Potenza, Infini, Genius RFM), Face Tite RF, HIFU & Softwave.
Low level biostimulation describes biostimulatory injectables, and multipass RF devices, skin care & LEDs (extremely low level biostimulation) & home use devices. I am a believer of employing as many low level biostimulatory avenues as possible- if you can afford it.
What are hyaluronic acid serums & how do they differ from HA based biostimulators?
Hyaluronic acid serums are awesome as moisturizers & humectants. They can be purchased online, at The Formulated or in-clinic. HAs trap water & provide hydration to the upper layers of skin.
HA injectables (as the name suggests), provide deep dermal hydration, which cannot be achieved with skin care.
Why can we learn from Europe & Asia when it comes to biostimulatory injectables? The good & the bad.
Asia & Europe are well ahead of Australia when it comes to the use of dermal fillers & collagen stimulating injectables, thanks in part to our strict TGA assessment. Australia is between 8 to 3 years behind Europe & Asia respectively, however it is not all bad news, as other countries have largely ironed out the potential problems & limitations before injectables hit our shores.
For example, we know how to modulate the inflammatory responses of PCL injectables, as well as the limitations of hyped injectables like Profhilo.
Davin’s viewpoint on biostimulators
This is a relatively new concept in Australia with the recent trend after the release of Profhilo to the market in 2022. Fast forward to 2023 & there are over half a dozen biostimulators in Australia.
The purpose of biostimulatory injectables are three-fold.
- To provide low level background biostimulation to mitigate the loss of collagen over time. Important concept to understand as, by definition, mitigation is something that you do not see. Factor in a 30% reduction in collagen during the perimenopausal years & commencement of injectables during this time can, in the best case, prevent or at the very least reduce an inevitable reduction of collagen.
- Provide collagen production that is in excess of age-related collagen loss, or a ‘positive yield’
- Provide skin hydration due to a reduction in hyaluronic acid. HA levels, much like collagen levels, will decrease in time. This is especially true in patients who are sun damaged.
With choice comes confusion as clinicians & patients struggle to understand what the best type of biostimulatory injectable is to use.
Here is my take on things. Ideally, providing the budget allows for it, two types of biostimulators are required, at least for patients over the age of 40. Firstly, a hyaluronic acid based injectable to help hydrate the skin. Again, I emphasize this is very different from a hyaluronic acid-based filler (cross-linked) as dermal fillers provide tissue projection via volume displacement – replacement. Tissue hydration, in patients who are dermally ‘dehydrated’ will reduce wrinkles & some laxity, but this is not true fibrosis, or volume replacement.
The second type of biostimulator is concentrated at the true meaning of stimulation aimed at the fibroblast. If volume replacement is required, the choices include PLLA or CAH. Factor in 3-6 sessions based upon the deficit. If biostimulation is required with minimal volume gain, then PCL should be considered. Factor in 2-3 sessions, spaced 4 to 10 weeks apart.
Where do devices come in? Ideally devices such as low-level radiofrequency (Pelleve, NuEra, Venus, TriLift) can be incorporated into your program. These devices are aimed at providing some form of fibroblast stimulation, without the pain, expense, or downtime of high level biostimulation.
As for the diet & collagen? Evidence is lacking, however if you are inclined to take collagen supplements, they can be a good way to provide a placebo effect & can be beneficial for your joints. A diet high in antioxidants (legumes, leafy greens, fish, nuts, berries, botanicals), can provide a marginal improvement in photoaging.
*For appointments in our Sydney office, please contact Tracee at Dr Van Park’s clinic in the Eastern Suburbs. Kate, or myself are available for injectables.